Key Differences Between Traditional Publishing and Self-Publishing

Key Differences Between Traditional Publishing and Self-Publishing

As a writer, the ultimate goal is to see your hard work and dedication transformed into a book, standing proudly on a bookstore shelf or comfortably residing on another reader’s nightstand. Getting your book from your computer to those bookshelves, however, can be a complex and confusing journey. These paths usually lead to two destinations: traditional publishing and self-publishing.

Definition of Traditional Publishing

In traditional publishing, the writer submits their manuscript to an established publishing house. The publisher takes care of the intricacies of producing, marketing, and distributing the book. Typically, the writer receives an advance–money upfront–and then royalties from the book sales. These can vary, but often hover around 10% of the book’s retail price.

  • The publisher assumes all risks
  • The author doesn’t pay for anything
  • There’s potential for a larger audience with better distribution

Definition of Self-Publishing

On the other hand, self-publishing involves the writer taking on the publisher’s role. They are responsible for editing, formatting, creating a cover, and marketing the book themselves or hiring professionals to do it. Earnings in this case, however, are significantly higher with authors usually pocketing around 60-70% of their book’s price.

  • The author takes all the risks
  • The author has complete creative control
  • Potential for higher profit margins. Both of these publishing models have their pros and cons, and it’s ultimately up to you to determine which one aligns best with your goals as an author.

Traditional Publishing

With the overflowing creativity within you just itching to reach audiences worldwide, it’s important to understand the intricacies of the publishing world before you dive in. Let’s kick off with traditional publishing.

Process of Traditional Publishing

Traditional publishing involves submitting your manuscript to a publishing house. If interest is shown, a publishing contract is offered where the publishers take full charge of editing, formatting, marketing, distributing, and selling your book. You, as the author, usually receive an advance and royalties thereafter. It does, however, take time – sometimes upwards of a year or two from the contract signing for your book to hit the market.

Pros of Traditional Publishing

There are quite a few advantages to going the traditional route. High-quality editing, design, and marketing services are usually included. Additionally:- Your book is more likely to add a credible review or two under its belt, and might even get shelved in bookstores.

  • You have the advantage of placement in libraries and bookstores, which can boost sales significantly.
  • Working with an experienced team at a publishing house can also help you escalate your writing and exposure to the literary world.

Cons of Traditional Publishing

But the traditional publishing world isn’t without its snags. Some potential downsides include:- It can be challenging to get your manuscript accepted by a traditional publisher. Many manuscripts are rejected outright, and even high-quality works may not get picked up.
– You will likely have less creative control over your book – from title to cover design to marketing.
– Though you’re given an advance, royalties thereafter can be low, and not all books earn out their advance.
– The process is far lengthier; it can take up to two years for your book to hit the market.Time to weigh up what matters most to you and your work. Is it the credibility, marketing, and shelf-space? Or maybe it’s creative control and speed. Whatever factors you’re juggling, read on as we venture into the world of self-publishing next!


When it comes to controlling your own literary path, self-publishing is king. Let’s delve into what self-publishing involves, its pros, and its cons.

Process of Self-Publishing

The beauty of self-publishing is, you hold the creative reins. After all, it’s your book! After your manuscript is ready, you’ll need to decide on formatting, cover design, and the finer details of production. These may well involve hiring experts (like a cover designer or an editor) unless you’re a jack-of-all-trades. Once your book has your stamp of approval, you’ll head on to distributing it yourself via platforms like Amazon, Smashwords, or IngramSpark.

Pros of Self-Publishing

  • Plenty of Creative Control: Unlike traditional publishing, you have full control over the content, cover design, title, and marketing strategies. It’s a creative freedom that many authors truly relish.
  • Profit Share: You get the lion’s share of profit as there’s no publisher to split proceeds with. This can be quite exciting especially if your book does well.
  • Speed: Traditional publishers may take years to get your book out. But in self-publishing? Your book is out once you hit the publish button.

Cons of Self-Publishing

  • It’s All On You: While control is great, it can be overwhelming to handle it all. All the work from proofreading, to cover design, and marketing is on you unless you hire help.
  • Upfront costs: Paying for professional editing, formatting, cover design, and marketing can all add up. You’ll need to invest some money before making any.
  • Hard to get into bookstores: Bookstores, particularly the big-chain ones, are still more comfortable working with traditional publishers.There you have it, the nuts and bolts of self-publishing. A rewarding path that allows ultimate control, but one that also calls for resourcefulness and resilience.

Comparison between Traditional Publishing and Self-Publishing

The publishing industry has seemingly undergone a revolution in recent years, opening up a hot debate on traditional publishing vs self-publishing. Both processes have their own unique perks, pitfalls, and quirks. Let’s delve into a detailed comparison looking at distinct factors like costs, control, time factor, distribution, marketing, and revenue.


One of the most notable differences is cost. Traditional publishing involves no upfront out-of-pocket costs to the author. The publisher assumes all financial risks and covers layout design, editing, cover art, and marketing. The downside? Your share of the profits would be less.In contrast, self-publishing requires you to shoulder all of the expenses in producing and marketing a book. However, the world of technology has made self-publishing significantly cheaper; even free!

  • Traditional Publishing: Zero upfront cost but less profit-share
  • Self-publishing: Higher upfront cost but higher profit-share

Control and Creative Freedom

Control over the work is another significant area where these two veers apart. With traditional publishing, the publisher has the final say in everything from cover design to content edits, title, and the release date. In the self-publishing route, you retain complete control over every aspect of your book. You are the boss!

Time to Market

When it comes to speed to market, self-publishing takes the cake. Once your book is ready to publish, you can theoretically publish it within weeks on platforms like Amazon. Traditional publishing generally takes much longer, with processes that can stretch to a year or more after acceptance of a manuscript.

Distribution and Reach

Traditional publishers have the advantage of a vast network of bookstores and libraries, which still matters, despite the surge in eBooks and online distributors. On the flip side, self-published authors have to work harder to get their books on shelves, but they can easily and instantaneously reach a global audience online.

Marketing and Promotion

Whether you follow the traditional route or self-publish, expect to roll up your sleeves and get involved in marketing. Publishers do promote their books, but authors are often expected to do a significant share of the promotion. The advantage for self-publishers here is you keep all of the proceeds from your marketing efforts.

Revenue and Royalties

The traditional publishing model typically offers you an advance and then royalties if your book sells well. With self-publishing, you get a higher percentage of the sales. However, remember that the reach of a traditional publisher could mean more sales overall.Beware, this is not a one-size-fits-all kind of situation. This comparison is designed merely to highlight the differences and give you the knowledge to make the right choice for your publishing journey. Keep writing, keep exploring!

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Traditional Publishing and Self-Publishing

When diving into the book industry as an author, you essentially have two main avenues to choose from: traditional publishing and self-publishing. Both options have their unique pros and cons, and the choice highly depends on various factors. Let’s delve into each factor to guide you in making the best choice for your publishing journey.

Creative Control

One of the significant points authors consider when choosing a publishing method is creative control. With self-publishing, you have complete control over the look and feel of your book. This means you decide the cover design (yes, it’s okay to judge a book by its cover here!) and you also get to decide what goes in and what stays out of your book. As for traditional publishing, the power scales tend to lean more towards the publishing house, meaning you may have to sacrifice some control over the creative process.

Time Commitment

The time you are able to commit also plays a monumental role in deciding your publishing path. Traditional publishing can take considerable time, often taking over a year from manuscript to bookshelf. On the other hand, self-publishing can be a quicker route, especially with platforms like Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing. But remember, you’re shouldering more of the responsibilities yourself, which can be time-consuming in its own right.

Financial Investment

  • Traditional Publishing: You typically don’t have it pay any upfront costs, and it can even amount to an advance payment. However, you’ll eventually have to share royalties with the publisher.
  • Self-Publishing: There is a financial investment that you’ll need to consider. This is typically covering the costs of editing, designing, format, and sometimes even buying stock photos for your cover design. The advantage is you earn all the profits yourself.

Marketing and Promotion

Marketing is crucial, regardless of your publication method. Traditional publishers come equipped with experienced marketing teams that can help you reach a wider audience, at least initially. For self-publishers, you’re largely on your own, although you do have flexibility in deciding how you market and who you market to.

Long-term Goals

Lastly, it’s crucial to consider your long-term goals. If you enjoy having creative control and you’re more inclined towards entrepreneurship, self-publishing could be your game. But if your dream is to see your book in the prominent windows of bookstores across the country and don’t mind sharing creative control, you might lean more towards traditional publishing. In conclusion, there’s no wrong or right; only what best suits your book, resources, and career aspirations.

Success Stories and Case Studies

Let’s dive in headfirst by exploring some extraordinary triumphs in both traditional publishing and self-publishing. These success stories serve as guiding lights, showcasing the potential present on both sides of the publishing spectrum.

Success Stories of Traditionally Published Authors

Traditionally published authors oftentimes come with household names. An iconic example is JK Rowling, the author of the ‘Harry Potter’ series. She received multiple rejections from publishers before Bloomsbury finally said yes!

  • Stephen King is another such case. His debut novel ‘Carrie’ was initially rejected, but it was eventually published traditionally, catapulting him to fame.
  • Margaret Atwood, known for ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’, is also a traditionally published author who saw major success.

Success Stories of Self-Published Authors

On the flip side, we have some equally inspiring self-publishing success stories.

  • E.L James, author of ‘Fifty Shades of Grey,’ originally self-published her works online before they gained immense popularity.
  • Hugh Howey’s ‘Wool’ began as a self-published short story, eventually developing into a novel and being picked up by a major publisher.
  • Amanda Hocking is another self-publishing success with her vampire series, finding an audience of millions entirely on her own.Both paths have their own triumphs, showing that great stories can find their readers, no matter the method of publishing.


Let’s take a short stroll down memory lane to capture the essence of our discussion about traditional publishing and self-publishing.

Recap of the main differences between traditional publishing and self-publishing

Traditional publishing involves a layered journey of landing a literary agent, who then pitches your work to publishing behemoths. They handle the grunt work of editing, cover designing (often involving stock photos), marketing, and distribution. However, they exercise considerable control, and the financial gains, unless you’re a bestseller, can be meager.Self-publishing, on the other hand, ties the reins firmly to your hands. You’re responsible for every step, from the first draft to the final book copies. It offers swift deployment, creative control, and higher royalty rates. But remember, it can be taxing in terms of time, effort, and upfront costs.

Encouragement to make an informed decision based on personal goals and resources

Venturing into the book industry is an exciting journey but remember there’s no one-size-fits-all method. Weigh the pros and cons of each route holistically. Think about your personal goals, the resources at your disposal, and the level of control you desire. Whether it’s the trodden path of traditional publishing or the adventurous highway of self-publishing, your unique situation and aspirations should guide your voyage. Never forget, it’s not just about getting published; it’s about sharing your voice, your vision, and your passion with the world. Now go forth, and create magic! We’re rooting for you.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *